$5,923raised
$9,200valuation
Sign in to trade

Project description

We're organizing OPTIC, the Open Prediction Tournament for Intercollegiate Competition — an in-person, intercollegiate forecasting tournament in Boston this spring.

*NOTE: This page is no longer updated (as of mid-April). We successfully conducted the April 22 tournament and in the process of scaling up. See our website (opticforecasting.com) for more updated public information, and contact the organizers (opticforecasting@gmail.com, opticforecasting.com/contact) for more updated investor information.

Goals

Our main goal is to build the forecasting community by encouraging college students in relevant fields (international relations, statistics, politics, computer science, etc), which would:

  1. Create a larger and more diverse pool of future and present forecasters and superforecasters, which increases the quality of aggregated & individual forecasts, and

  2. Normalize the field of forecasting to the general public, strengthening public support, knowledge, and awareness of the practice of rigorous forecasting.

We expect this spring’s tournament to serve as a pilot program for a future, long-term, recurring academic league similar to existing intercollegiate academic competitions like debate, mock trial, or model UN. Currently, students say that they’re on the debate team, or the MUN team; we want students to say that they’re on their college’s forecasting team.

Our primary goal is to add an intellectually energetic field of college students to the existing forecasting community through an engaging, fun, enjoyable event. Competitors will refine their forecasting skills, improving their ability to contribute to the forecasting community and to the future decision-making of key institutions. We’ll be shooting for a collaborative, competitive, and fun environment over forecasting accuracy. Over the long run, we want this tournament to increase interest in forecasting among college students, identify more superforecasters, and encourage the development of diverse forecasting communities within and between colleges.

Logistics

Venue

We’ll be renting out a large venue in Boston, but our backup plan is to use a university venue (likely at Harvard).

Attending universities

Boston-area college students — including those from regionally-adjacent colleges, like Brown or Yale — will form university teams. Depending on the size of these university teams, team captains may choose to split into sub-teams.

Question info

During the event, teams will make probabilistic predictions on topics ranging from Russia/Ukraine and China/US, to AI development, to global economics and indices, to COVID rates and the avian flu, as well as predicting more fun questions on sports games, popular news, public-figure tweets, etc. The timeframe of these questions is on the scale of weeks to months.

Prizes & other fun stuff

Prize money will be granted to the top three teams based on forecasting accuracy, as well as some prizes being granted to high-quality forecasting rationales. Since a primary objective of the event is to be fun and enjoyable for the competitors, we're inviting a few speakers (speakers TBD), as well as providing snacks, merch, and covering transportation costs, as funding allows.

Expected results

Achieving high competitor turnout for this first event would be around 120 competitors; from aggregating about ten independent estimates from the organizers of OPTIC and Harvard EA leadership, we project a turnout of between thirty and 120 competitors, with a median of around 40-60. We expect future events to grow significantly, conditional on the success of this spring’s tournament.

Relevant information about the outcome of the project — including the shape of our plans to continue/discontinue future tournaments — will be available to investors and funders by September 1st (the oracular funding deadline) and probably well before. 

What is your track record on similar projects?

Our core team is Tom Shlomi (Harvard), Saul Munn (Brandeis), and Jingyi Wang (Brandeis). We’ve also been in close contact with a number of people in the forecasting and EA communities who’ve run similar projects in the past and who’ve been incredibly helpful, including: Juan Gil (a prominent community builder for Boston EA), Ozzie Gooen (president of the Quantified Uncertainty Research Institute, founder of Guesstimate), Henry Tolchard (co-organized an online, intercollegiate forecasting tournament in 2022), and others.

Additionally, all core team members are Boston-area university EA organizers — and we’re well-connected with the regional EA scene, which will help expedite and maximize outreach efforts, advising processes, etc.

Tom Shlomi

Tom organizes for Harvard EA, and is currently running a workshop series at Harvard focused on teaching practical forecasting skills.  He is also a former summer research fellow at the Center on Long-term Risk and long-time forecaster on Metaculus and Manifold, and currently holds 2nd place on the Manifold AI timelines leaderboard.

Saul Munn

Saul organizes for Brandeis EA (BEA). He coordinates the BEA Reading Group and helps to facilitate the BEA Introductory Fellowship.

He co-organized a 250-person festival for Purim (major Jewish holiday), as well as numerous smaller (15-50+ person) events at his synagogue. As co-president of his high school Jewish Student Union, he co-organized monthly 50-200+ person events for two years.

Additionally, he’s helped out at a few high school debate tournaments of similar size and scope.

Jingyi Wang

Jingyi is the treasurer for Brandeis EA. She liaises with EA Group Funds and the university treasury board to acquire funding, and ensures the Brandeis EA budget is used appropriately. 


How will you spend your funding?

We’re requesting 1,265 USD in order to launch a minimum viable product, but we strongly hope to raise additional funding. This will cover food and smaller prizes.

Our mainline request is 6,000 USD (total) for a strongly valuable & impactful tournament. The additional funding will allow us to book a better venue, increase prizes, and enable us to fund transportation for speakers and participants and we expect further funding up to 13,125 USD (total) to result in substantially better outcomes.

For a more detailed breakdown of where the money will be spent, see our budget linked below.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ftj4mGcKBGFl4MiWqlehzaka_-8qu6FuSsuZnhQY1a8/edit?usp=sharing

holds 0%
saulmunn avatar

Saul Munn

about 1 year ago

Here's a Notion doc of the below :)


ACX Forecasting Mini-Grants Update

Hey! We’re posting this update as ACX Forecasting Mini-Grants begins the retroactive evaluation period. A quick timeline:

  • We ran a pilot, intercollegiate forecasting competition in April 2023. It went really well!

  • We wrote a (detailed) postmortem on the pilot competition in May 2023.

  • We kept working on OPTIC over the summer, and have a lot of plans for the future (some specifics are below).

Rachel & Austin wanted all of the projects to answer the questions below. If you want the details on the pilot competition, check out the postmortem, but it doesn’t include our future plans.

We’d also be happy to meet — online or in person! Reach out to opticforecasting@gmail.com, or come chat with us at Manifest. Tom is based in the Bay, Jingyi is based in Boston, and Saul is in the Bay for September and Boston for October.


  1. How much money have you spent so far? Have you gotten more funding from other sources? Do you need more funding?

    Answers detailed in the table below. We received funding from Manifund and the Long Term Future Fund (LTFF).

    Total Manifund LTFF Original Funding 6001 3901 2100 Used 2208 Committed* 3000 Leftover 792

    *The prize money has not yet been given out, but has been committed — it’s sitting in our bank account waiting to go to the winners.

    Our original Manifund project was funded to run a pilot, intercollegiate forecasting competition. This original, pilot competition doesn’t need more funding — it’s already been completed — but OPTIC as an organization has expanded. We’re seeking funding to run additional competitions and help support forecasting clubs. We are likely to have a moderate through a corporate sponsor and some forecasting organizations, and have pending applications more funding through Open Philanthropy, the Long-Term Future Fund, and Manifund. We also applied to Lightspeed and received no funding.

  2. How is the project going? (a few paragraphs)

    1. The pilot went well (see the postmortem for a detailed account), and we’re planning to run 2-4 tournaments in the fall. (This is dependent primarily on funding & high-quality hires.)

    2. We’ve adjusted the mission of OPTIC from purely running forecasting competitions to generally promoting collegiate forecasting. At this point, that means expanding our reach to support about 2-4 forecasting clubs this semester, and more in future semesters. We’re providing fiscal support (fundraising now!), organizational mentorship, instructional content, and outreach materials.

  3. How well has your project gone compared to where you expected it to be at this point? (Score from 1-10, 10 = Better than expected)

    1. Our scoring rule:

      1. 1 = much worse than expected

      2. 5 = exactly as expected

      3. 10 = much better than expected

    2. Average response: 7.83

      1. Saul’s response: 8

      2. Tom’s response: 8

      3. Jingyi’s response: 7.5

  4. Are there any remaining ways you need help, besides more funding?

    1. Yes! We need:

      1. competitors! Sign up on our website :)

      2. organizers! We’re running competitions in the fall in at least Boston and the Bay Area, and potentially DC and London. We’re bottlenecked on local organizing capacity, and finding good organizers will determine which we can run.

      3. speakers/panelists! We are still looking for speakers/panelists, especially for the non-Bay Area competitions.

  5. Any other thoughts or feedback?

    1. Nothing other than gratitude toward Rachel, Austin, and Scott for setting this up :)

holds 0%
saulmunn avatar

Saul Munn

over 1 year ago

Update: we held the (successful!!) pilot competition! A postmortem of the pilot competition is below — take a look and share your thoughts!

[ https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/4p8RpK2fYKFmEcA9w/optic-forecasting-comp-pilot-postmortem?commentId=T2nKYCfgyyBGxCGP3 ]

holds 0%
saulmunn avatar

Saul Munn

over 1 year ago

We have a website: opticforecasting.com!

You can contact us directly at opticforecasting.com/contact :)