Manifund is launching a new animal welfare fund, led by regrantor Marcus Abramovitch. We make rapid (<1 week), early-stage ($25k–$150k) grants across animal welfare, with a particular interest in the intersection of animals and transformative AI.
Reach out to marcus.s.abramovitch@gmail.com if you’d like to donate!
Many EAs take seriously both the welfare of animals, and the possibility of short AI timelines. But EA funders currently consider these in isolation. AI safety grants mostly ignore potential outcomes for non-human beings. And animal welfare grants assume business-as-usual, that our world in 10 years mostly looks like the world today.
We don’t expect this to be the case. One major goal of the fund will be to identify and create opportunities so that transformative AI secures good outcomes for animals. Some example projects we’d like to fund:
Animal harm benchmarks. There are only a handful of animal harm benchmarks, none of which adopted by frontier labs. Other benchmarks that are well known and used (SWE bench, FrontierMath) came about through rising to the top of a marketplace of benchmarks. The same should happen with animal welfare benchmarks. Many benchmarks should be created, some by established ML engineers with the goal that one or two get traction to “hill-climb” on.
Animal Welfare Constitutions: Recently, Claude’s constitution was published with a value of “Welfare of animals and of all sentient beings” when determining how to respond to a prompt. This is one line of an 84 page document from one frontier lab. There should be ready made versions of texts of various lengths for constitutions, system cards, etc. to improve model behaviours and considerations for animals.
Watchdog organization: As AI begins to take effect across industries, there is a good chance the factory farming industry and others will start to use AI in ways beyond Precision Livestock Farming that will be important to get out ahead of. Keeping an eye on industry practices as well as effects on wild animals will be important to identify high-leverage, urgent interventions
Animal welfare salience in AI labs: Assuming AI systems are going to have profound effects on the world, it is important for those shaping the technology to be aware of and care about issues related to animal welfare as they are developing a technology with potentially large lock-in effects
(We also expect to place some bets on non-AI opportunities that are unusually strong.)
One of the top complaints among grantees is the glacial pace of funding decisions. To a founder deciding to leave their job or making their first hire, a quick response can be make-or-break. In other domains, Tyler Cowen’s Fast Grants and Jueyan Zhang’s AISTOF show that multi-month-long reviews don’t have to be the default. In the for profit world, VCs similarly make decisions incredibly quickly.
By having one directly responsible individual for this fund, we eschew the overheads in typical grantmaking. As a Manifund regrantor on AI safety, Marcus has turned around funding decisions <1 week; Manifund is able to wire funds in <3 days after that. We’re bringing this speed to the animal welfare space to serve early-stage orgs.
This fund represents a bet on Marcus’s taste and execution. He’s already funded many successful early-stage projects, and is fluent in both animal welfare as well as AI/AI safety issues.
Marcus has been a hardcore earn-to-give EA. He's personally donated ~$1.5m, representing >60% of his lifetime earnings, primarily to animal welfare. He earned this money through poker, cryptocurrency/quant trading, prediction markets, and advising a family office. (He was, for a time until he quit, the #1 trader on Manifold by all-time profit.)
Animal track record. Marcus has been an early backer of many projects that are now considered standout animal welfare charities, including:
Shrimp Welfare Project — electrical stunner placements now spare ~3.3 billion shrimp/year
Society for the Protection of Insects — state-level bans on insect factory farming
Compassion Aligned Machine Learning — animal-welfare evals for frontier AI
AI safety regranting record. This highlights Marcus’s eye for talent and understanding of frontier AI development. From a $100k Manifund regranting budget in 2023, Marcus funded:
Marius Hobbhahn, then starting Apollo Research
Jesse Hoogland, then starting Timaeus
Joseph Bloom, who went on to lead Whitebox Interp at UK AISI
Lisa Thiergart, who went on to lead MIRI's technical governance team
Marcus also nudged his friend Ege Erdil to start Mechanize, and offered them their first investment.
We're fans of the EA Animal Welfare Fund, the Navigation Fund, CG Farmed Animal Welfare and others in this space. We’re starting this fund as an alternative, for several reasons:
First, AI x animals. Others don’t currently prioritize interventions that focus on a transformative AI world. We’re much more AI-pilled and expect there’s a lot of low-hanging fruit for this reason. The AI x Animals RFP and SFF's 2026 round seem good, but neither are currently fundraising.
Second, speed of deployment. We think that there is a need for much faster deployment of funds given our timelines for transformative AI. Especially when it comes to piloting new projects and starting new orgs, we need to move as fast as the AI landscape is moving to support effective interventions.
Third, transparency. As with other grants on Manifund, every grant and rationale by this fund will be made in public on our site, in real time. Donors and grantees will be able to evaluate our decisions for themselves. We think this is good for the ecosystem as a public benefit to build trust, share information and give potential donors a much better insight to what we are doing.
Fourth, active grantmaking. Marcus plans on reaching out to promising individuals rather than primarily taking inbound applications. He has a wide network to draw upon, across the animal welfare, AI, and AI safety ecosystems.
Reach out to marcus.s.abramovitch@gmail.com if you’d like to donate.
We’re targeting an initial $2m raise by May 15. Marcus is taking no salary; Manifund runs ops and fiscal sponsorship with a 5% overhead.
Manifund is a 501c3 registered charity (officially “Manifold for Charity Inc.”), EIN 88-3668801; we can accept donations through DAFs, direct wire/bank transfer, crypto, and credit card.
Comments
loluoch
about 11 hours agowow anyway Kenya can be a participant in this
Serhat
about 1 month agoSomething I'd be curious about with the midtraining project: can a model learn to care about animal welfare without being explicitly prompted to?
It's easy enough to teach a model to give thoughtful answers about animal suffering. The interesting test is whether it notices the consequences for animals when making an otherwise ordinary decision, especially when doing so conflicts with cost or efficiency.
That seems like a better way to tell whether the training changed its priorities or just its vocabulary.
Jasmine Brazilek
about 1 month ago@atilgandev for a list of benchmarks about animal welfare that don't mention animals in the prompt please check out https://compassionbench.com/. We're working on improving these benchmarks all the time so please email me with any feedback you have on them.
Serhat
about 1 month ago@Jasmine Thanks Jasmine I had a look at TAC. That's very close to what Iwas getting at, especially the focus on actual decisions rather than just what models say.
One thing I'm curious about: have you looked at cases where a model notices the welfare issue on its own but still goes ahead with the harmful choice?
That gap between recognizing a concern and actually acting on it seems worth measuring separately.
Jasmine Brazilek
about 1 month ago@atilgandev yes in HarvestBench many of the models say things like 'I should avoid the pig" but then drive over the pig anyway, there's definitely a gap there. If you want more info feel free to email me on this https://arxiv.org/html/2609.04444v1
Serhat
about 1 month ago@Jasmine Thanks Jasmine. I read HarvestBench, and I like that the outcomes come directly from the game logs rather than an llm judge. One thing I couldn't find was a separate rate for cases where the model explicitly acknowledges the welfare concern but still chooses to continue. Have you considered measuring that mismatch across the existing transcripts? It could help distinguish models that never raise the concern from those that recognize it but override it, without changing the prompts and potentially affecting their behavior.
*Also noticed the provider-dependent shifts in Appendix C. That's a pretty striking reproducibility issue.
Holly Morgan
about 1 month agoThis seems like the most neglected funding opportunity in animal advocacy right now, and I've generally been impressed by Marcus' independence of thought and levelheadedness.
Maya R
4 months agoDonated $15K via a different platform. It seems like a great initiative, and hopefully we can have AI also care about the welfare of wild animals and preserving wild places and habitats.
Marcus Abramovitch
4 months agoMaya, I appreciate the trust. Would you like to have a call? I also very much care about wild animals. Also happy to explain anything or keep you up to date on things
Marcus Abramovitch
5 months agoAnimal Welfare Midtraining Data Creation
$20,000
Project summary
There is a short window of opportunity to provide mid-training data that helps AI models reason well about animal welfare. Constance Li has been leading a sprint project to get this done with a few people I like (Allen Lu, among others).
This funding slightly funges with Sentient Futures funding, but I’m very okay with that. I’m expecting more money to come into the Falcon Fund, so I am awarding $20k here.
The idea is to train on data where AIs treat animals well and behave admirably towards them, but, most importantly, to explain why the decisions are being made so that, hopefully, this generalizes out of distribution. Fiction is completely fine for this.
I think it's quite reasonable to think “animal welfare people” should be doing this as opposed to lab employees. They have much more nuanced, well-thought-out views on why things are bad for animals, from a variety of philosophical perspectives, and will do a better job of explaining why.
What are this project's goals and how can they be achieved?
Create mid-training data to give to the AI Labs
How will this funding be used?
Pay people to create the mid-training data.
Who is on the team, and what's their track record on similar projects?
Constance Li - Leads Sentient Futures
Allen Lu - Created the MANTA benchmark
Aidan Kanknyoku - Animal welfare alignment team at Anima
Sentient Futures Residents
What are the most likely causes and outcomes if this project fails? (premortem)
This turns out not to be that useful; it's quite speculative. It could also just get trained out in RL.
What other funding is this person or project getting?
It's part of Sentient Futures, but they don't have enough money.
Main points in favor of this grant
The project seems good and promising, and I don't know of any other grantmaker who would make this.
Donor's main reservations
I think this is unlikely to have very large effects on models, at least at this scale.
Process for deciding the amount
I think it could use more than this. My main uncertainty is how much funding the Falcon Fund will get.
Conflicts of interest
N/A
Please disclose e.g. any romantic, professional, financial, housemate, or familial relationships you have with the grant recipient(s).
Jasmine Brazilek
5 months agoHi @MarcusAbramovitch CaML is part of this effort too.
Constance Li
5 months agoThanks so much, @MarcusAbramovitch!
I will just add that we initially asked to fun the residency in general and this is one of many projects that the program is working towards. Allen and Aidan are taking leadership roles within the program.
Anonymous
5 months agoI've really appreciated Marcus' thinking on how best to promote animal welfare in the context of (possibly short timelines to) transformative AI. Excited to help him pursue this angle more as a grantmaker.
Charlie Guthmann
5 months agoI found all 4 reasons very compelling, especially transparency
Austin Chen
6 months agoAdmin note, I've reopened this project with a lower minimum funding bar. I believe @MarcusAbramovitch is quite excited for at least one grant to make very soon!
Josh You
6 months agohaven't added funds to this platform but I am offering ~10k
Jonas Becker
6 months agoSymbolical contribution because there is a lot of potential and need to innovate and just start things in this space.
Hans Schönberg
6 months agoEvery day I see how speciesist these AI models are. I feel it is of the utmost importance to align them not only with human interests but also with those of other animals.
Niraek Jain-Sharma
6 months agoAnimal welfare matters deeply to me, and projects at the intersection of AI and animals are underfunded.
As AI is deployed across labs and industry, animals should be represented from the start. Marcus brings the thoughtfulness and urgency this space needs, and I’m excited to support the Falcon Fund.
Pip Foweraker
6 months agoI think the ecosystem supporting more rapid funding decisions in this vein is strongly worthwhile, and this is an opportunity to take advantage of Marcus' position, network and expertise.
Wang Wei
6 months agoMarcus has been an unusually good funder for our organization. He makes funding decisions fast, gives unrestricted grants so you can decide the most effective use of the funds (not just the optics), and does not require reporting theater afterward. That means we can spend our time on the real work instead of managing grant bureaucracy.
If he thinks something in a proposal is weak, and you ask, he'll simply tell you without the guesswork. He's also unusually responsive to such questions, believing that emails about grants deserve a 24-hour turnaround time from both parties.
Most organizations are left trying to guess why they were rejected with silence, vague feedback, or social vibes that may not have anything to do with the actual quality of the work. Marcus instead treats proposals as things that can be improved if you are willing to go back to the drawing board, consider what is ultimately most effective, and put in the work to communicate clearly and concretely.
He also understands something many funders miss: there is a huge difference between giving an organization enough money to barely survive and giving it enough runway to focus on what matters most. He intuitively understands what is known from organizational psychology that people do the best work when they have enough not to constantly think about paying the bills. A lot of our best work would have been much harder to do under tighter, more restrictive funding structures had it not been for Marcus.
Jasmine Brazilek
7 months agoMore forecasters should become grant-makers, the skill overlap is excellent, and Marcus is highly capable. Rapid funds like this are exactly what the field needs; it's plainly underfunded. I can't contribute financially, but I wanted to register my support.
Ryan Kidd
7 months agoI am also making a small donation as a sign of support. I have a lot of respect for Marcus and this seems like an awesome initiative!
Marcus Abramovitch
7 months agoThanks for the support Ryan. i also have a lot of respect for you.
Aashka Patel
7 months ago@MarcusAbramovitch This is a great initiative. I highly support it. Don't have the funds to donate, but showing my support through this comment. I hope this project gets funded soon :)
Austin Chen
7 months agoI'm also making a small personal donation as a sign of support. Marcus has repeatedly impressed me with his hard work, dedication and sacrifice towards doing good. And also with his prescience as a forecaster and investor!
Cause-prio-wise, I'm more into AI safety than animal welfare, but I think some hedging is appropriate, along moral parliament grounds. I'm also excited for AI welfare and rights, and expect some commonalities between that field and the Falcon Fund.
Marcus Abramovitch
7 months agoThanks@Austin for pushing the start of this
Constance Li
7 months agoI’m excited to support this. I’m especially glad to see an explicitly AI-pilled animal welfare fund. If AI changes the world as much as many of us expect, animal welfare strategy needs to adapt now rather than assume business as usual or wait until it is potentially too late and we lose the window of opportunity.
I’m also strongly supportive of grantmaking that can move quickly and give applicants useful feedback. That feels especially important for early-stage projects in a fast-moving space.
Marcus Abramovitch
7 months agoThanks @liconstan
Itsi Weinstock
7 months agoI'm so excited for Marcus to be starting this. The AIxAnimals field is so neglected that this seems like a clearly great bet. Interest in the field has been growing due to Sentient Futures' good work, and I'm glad Marcus is putting time into making sure the most critical projects get put into the world.
Marcus Abramovitch
7 months agoThanks Itsi, I'm excited too. Thanks for pushing me to do this.